Is Led Zeppelin’s ‘Good Moments Lousy Times’ Just about anything Like the Rolling Stones Tune of the Very same Title?

When Led Zeppelin launched its debut album in 1969, it caught the interest of musicians for a range of causes. Jeff Beck and Rod Stewart (then of the Jeff Beck Team) undoubtedly recognized, as Zeppelin’s edition of “You Shook Me” one particular-upped the Beck version. (Stewart stewed above that for a long time.)

“Babe, I’m Gonna Depart You,” the 2nd track on Led Zeppelin (aka “I“), inevitably grabbed the focus of Anne Bredon, who’d composed the tune prior to Joan Baez recording it on a ’62 album. Though Zep mentioned it as “Traditional” on the album (as Baez had on hers), Bredon afterwards received songwriting credit.

The Rolling Stones, who realized Zep’s Jimmy Page perfectly, may have finished a double-consider when they noticed the track listing on his band’s debut. That’s because opening tune “Good Moments Poor Times” experienced a title that was identical (minus a comma) to that of a Stones tune. But the similarities finished there.

The Rolling Stones produced ‘Good Moments, Terrible Times’ as a B-facet in 1964

British band ‘The Rolling Stones’ in 1964 | Charles Walls/Radio Situations by using Getty Illustrations or photos

Similar: Why Led Zeppelin Did not Sense Any Competitors With the Rolling Stones in the ’70s

The Rolling Stones scored their very first U.K. No. 1 with “It’s All Above Now,” the band’s go over of a ’64 Valentinos keep track of. For the B-aspect, the Stones recorded “Good Occasions, Lousy Moments,” a bluesy authentic penned by Keith Richards and Mick Jagger.

Given the breadth of good quality Stones materials, it is unlikely many rock supporters (even Stones die-hards) dwell pretty extended on “Good Instances, Poor Situations.” It is a B-facet for a reason, and that designation has not altered substantially considering that its ’64 launch. at?v=NPo9nivuewI

As significantly as its themes goes, blues supporters will not locate considerably new in “Good Moments, Bad Instances.” The narrator suggests he’s had his share of the terrible, and he ties that to getting rid of “you,” the unnamed female who’s taken her leave of him.

Immediately after bemoaning her loss, he asks if his departed love would not think about returning for much more superior instances. In the closing verse, Jagger sings about the loss of belief in the earth (or at the very least his). If there is no have faith in, “there’s gonna be war,” he bizarrely concludes.

Led Zeppelin’s ‘Good Periods Terrible Times’ shares only a title with the Stones tune

Led Zeppelin band photo, 1969
John Bonham, Robert Plant, Jimmy Site and John Paul Jones of Led Zeppelin | Chris Walter/WireImage

You only want to hear the opening guitar chords of Zeppelin’s “Good Instances Negative Times” to conclude it has practically nothing in common musically with the Stones tune of the similar name. This is a rocker, with growling guitar licks by Webpage and intense drumming by John Bonham.

When Robert Plant sings the opening strains, it turns into very clear the lyrics also have nothing at all in widespread with the Stones music. Plant sings about a youngster studying what it suggests to be person. And, now that he’s developed up, he’s just hoping to do just that.

In the refrain, we discover about some of the undesirable moments. Plant sings about the “woman who still left dwelling.” Just before, we get the only match amongst the Zeppelin lyrics and the Stones’: the phrase “I’ve had my share.”

Beyond that every day expression, there isn’t something the Zep song has in popular with the Stones’ B-side. That goes for tune high-quality as properly. When the Zep essential a solitary from the band’s debut album, “Good Instances Bad Times” was the a person they chosen.

Show More

Related Articles

Back to top button